Mon 30 Apr 2007
What is it about Hitler and April in Williamstown? Consider this article from April 27th in the New York Times.
Adolf Hitler, in brown-shirted effigy, disappeared suddenly from the Williams College campus this evening as a group of pro-fascist conservatives made off with an image of Der Fuehrer which had been prepared for destruction at the stake.
In the first riot at Williams in several years, over 500 mauling undergraduates broke up efforts to protest the failure of the German Government to act on an offer to buy all the Vienna Library books which have been condemned.
April 27th, 1938, that is.
The article’s title is “Hitler Effigy Saved From Williams Fire; Then Student Battle Rages Over Burning of Swastika.” Those were the days, eh? The last time there were “500 mauling undergraduates” at Williams was when? The Vanilla Ice concert?
Every Eph’s Hitler reading list should include Adolph Hitler: The Definitive Biography by Pulitzer Prize-winner John Toland ‘36 and The Psychopathic God: Adolf Hitler by Professor Robert G. L. Waite. If Professor Waite (my teacher in HIST 301) were still alive, he would have much to say about Mary Jane Hitler. Want to understand what the world was like 7 decades ago? Start with the Anschluss. Are there any historian readers who can educate us about the Vienna Library, circa April 1938?
The article continues:
Piles of pine coughs, boxes, crates and rubber tires blazed up in the midst of the Sophomore Quadrangle as floodlights played from dormitory windows. Fire houses were pulled out to flood the gathering and help preserve a Nazi swastika which had been brought on to supplant the Hitler image.
Are you an Eph undergraduate who cares about the past? Go look up the stories in the Record from the spring of 1938 and tell us what you find.
The student mob swayed up and down the field for half an hour in a fight over the swastika. Then its rescuer made off down the hill, while on a crowded balcony a moustached, undergraduate simulated Hitler in a brief appeal amid cheers and jeers.
And who was that nameless undergraduate, engaged in a stunt that — with the benefit of knowing what was then to come — seems much worse than that of Julia? What life did he go on to lead, which woman did he marry, what children did he raise? Should he have been marked, for the rest of his life, by one foolish moment of undergraduate stupidity? Was he not an Eph, like you, like me, like Julia?
2007-04-30 17:03:54
Nice find, David.
I’d argue that Julia’s stunt is less excusable, since she acted with full knowledge of what came after.
2007-04-30 17:05:44
this smacks of the worst sophistry imaginable; in 1938 the horrors of the Reich were (largely) potential and theoretical.
to put it more bluntly: Hitler was still (broadly) defensible in ‘38. He had restored the German economy, helped unite Germany and Austria, overthrown some of the sillier aspects of the Versailles treaty, installed an autobahn system that was the envy of the world, etc.
Hitler is not defensible in 2007, and appeals to the sundry “good things” that Hitler did are either meant to be a) deeply ironic or b) rooted in beliefs that are thought completely objectionable.
2007-04-30 17:15:01
And while we’re discussing Williams in the 30s, this past EphBlog post brings up an interesting episode:
http://www.ephblog.com/2004/11/15/Harvard-Williams-and-Nazis/
Since we’re feeling so sensitive about the rights of Nazis, hould we condemn the Williams College president in the 1930s for shutting down relations with Nazi universities?
2007-04-30 17:51:03
David: Again the mind boggles when considering your effort in finding this stuff!
2007-04-30 18:03:05
And students today mostly stay quiet if they have any opinions at all, but surely lack the consensus and interest to organize any social campaign. Are we relegated to looking back at the past with envy?
2007-04-30 18:23:42
Well, most people’s opinions will offend someone else, and political correctness has taught us that that is bad…
2007-04-30 18:59:06
“one foolish moment of undergraduate stupidity?”
Uh, no, David. From accounts of those who know Julia — and presented here for all to see — it’s just one in a series of many “foolish (if that’s how you care to benignly characterize them) moment(s)” and part of a pattern of insensitivity, even “sociopathology” (a designation that she — or Robert Shvern — has so ironically used in reference to the Eph community).
Too bad you’re falling for her “poor, poor, pitiful me” act hook, line, and sinker. I thought you were smarter than that.
2007-04-30 20:38:43
“One foolish moment of undergraduate stupidity” is followed immediately by an apology and expression of empathy for those offended. Even frat boys can figure that one out after a moment of undergrad stupity.
I’m sorry. Julia has expressed zero remorse, zero empathy, and has made it stunnigly clear that she is, in fact, an anti-semitic bigot.
2007-04-30 21:52:37
Kane- Some advice. Be a Marine.
Think about all that has been sacrificed since 1938 to make these kinds of acts legal, but not tolerated. What would a Marine do if he saw her boyfriend hanging such posters on his wall? Would a Marine tolerate it?
Be a Marine.