Sun 14 Sep 2008
Death of a Bank
Posted by Ronit under Alumni, Blather, Eph Pundit, Ephs in Politics, Williams History
Posted at 8:37 pmLehman Hall on the Williams campus is named after Herbert H. Lehman ‘99, the son of Meyer Lehman, who, along with his brothers Emmanuel and Henry, founded Lehman Brothers. The building bearing the Lehman name was completed in 1928, at the very height of a prolonged stock market boom. The Lehman Community Service Council is also, I think, named after Herb Lehman - along with a college, a couple of high schools, numerous buildings at other colleges, and a library and professorship at Columbia. Herbert Lehman ‘99 was one of those people that get many things named after them.
He worked at Lehman Brothers after graduating from Williams, but spent most of his adult life in public service. He was part of the General Staff Corps in Washington during World War I; after the end of the war, he worked for Al Smith’s gubernatorial and presidential campaigns, and served as Lt. Governor to FDR. After Roosevelt’s election to the Presidency in 1933, he became the Governor of New York, and was a very popular chief executive, with a reputation for nonpartisanship.
As Governor, Herbert Lehman was heavily involved in trying to mitigate the banking crisis of the 1930’s, shutting New York’s banks to try to avert a panic in March 1933. In an eerie premonition of this weekend’s meetings, he also tried, unsuccessfully, to organize a Wall Street rescue of the Bank of the United States in 1930; the failure to reach an agreement caused the largest bank failure in US history up to that point, one of the first large commercial bank failures of the Depression; depositors were not made whole, and the ensuing fear and hysteria led to thousands of other banks collapsing over the next few years (cf: Ron Chernow’s The House of Morgan, pp. 320-360).
During World War II, Herbert Lehman resigned his governorship to head the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration (UNRRA), an agency set up to assist citizens of nations that had been occupied by the Axis powers. He became a Senator from New York in 1949; in the Senate, he was a vocal critic of McCarthyism, voting for McCarthy’s censure, and was a strong supporter of Truman’s liberalism.
Towards the end of his life, he continued to work as an activist and reformer within New York’s Democratic party, alongside Eleanor Roosevelt. He was awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom in 1963, but died the day before the award ceremony, which took place on December 6 - just two weeks after JFK’s assassination. This was the citation that was read for Herbert Lehman in absentia by President Johnson: “Citizen and statesman, he has used wisdom and compassion as the tools of government and has made politics the highest form of public service.”
No one can hope for a better epitaph.
This weekend, the firm that Herbert’s father and uncles founded went out of business. American finance is being shaken to its core, and fear and foreboding have Wall Street in their grip. Lehman Brothers started as a dry-goods store in Montgomery, Alabama, and rose to become a storied investment bank. In partnership with Goldman, Sachs and Kuhn, Loeb (which it absorbed in the 1970s), it helped to finance many nascent industries over its 158-year history. The three Jewish banks did banking work for unglamorous and risky companies in retail, oil, and broadcasting; they promoted up-and-coming stocks, like Macy’s and RCA, that the Anglo half of Wall Street (the Morgans in particular) would not touch. They were risk-takers in the very best sense of the term. On 9/11/2001, Lehman Brothers survived a direct hit to its headquarters at the World Trade Center. Exactly seven years later, it was destroyed by the natural processes of the market and by its own derivatives and leverage. There is a crude analogy to be drawn here, but I won’t go there.
It is a near certainty now that Lehman’s 26,000 employees (including a significant number of Ephs) will lose their jobs. The impact on the financial system will be extremely serious (though you wouldn’t know it from watching the evening news, which has spent more time covering political nonsense). Many employees will lose both their jobs and their savings, because they were compensated in stock. This is the toughest, most challenging situation the financial system has seen in a very long time - if we are to believe Alan Greenspan, it is the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression.
We’ll reckon the wider economic fallout from this in due time; now, however, I’d just like to wish good luck to all Lehman employees, and goodbye to the Lehman name. One might be tempted to say, sic transit gloria mundi, were it not for the buildings and schools named after Herbert. Those will continue to stand, at least for the time being.
24 Responses to “ Death of a Bank ”
Comments:
Leave a Reply
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Pingback from Thank you, Ronit - for a break from the tedious and mind-numbing dissections on other threads … » EphBlog
September 15th, 2008 at 12:50 pm[...] Ronit on Lehman Bros. « Eph Pundit: Advice For Obama | [...]
-
Pingback from Current Market Events » EphBlog
September 18th, 2008 at 9:25 pm[...] about my thoughts on current market events? Read below. PTC asks How bad do you think this is going to get [...]

September 14th, 2008 at 8:45 pm
Well said.
September 14th, 2008 at 9:28 pm
I interned there after my junior year (luckily, I did not take the full time job offer). What was amazing to me at the time was the fact that a lot of the people I was working with had such a big percentage of their savings in LEH stock (and I am not talking about the people high up, but rather about the lowly associates and the like). You would think that people working in finance would know better. Dick Fuld and the management really wanted to create some kind of “ownership culture.” Why did so much people went along is beyond me. This should be a lesson: if you work in finance, you should really hedge and put your savings into oil company stocks and the like.
September 14th, 2008 at 9:57 pm
David -
A really terrific post. Thank you.
September 14th, 2008 at 9:59 pm
Who’re you calling ‘David’, buddy? :)
September 14th, 2008 at 10:11 pm
Herbert H. Lehman’s name is also attached to a modest grant-loan swap program intended to recognize campus leaders. I point this out reluctantly, because I was, much to my surprise, awarded one of these grants my senior year. In addition to the reduction in one’s loan obligation, recipients also received a copy of Lehman’s biography. I read mine at some point over the past 20 years and then placed it on the upper shelves of my office “wall of books.” Funnily enough, that’s one of the books that gets pulled out and commented on somewhat regularly by office visitors. I’ve always been proud to share an alma mater with such an illustrious figure. It is likely small consolation for those losing their jobs and/or nest eggs, but I’m glad Lehman’s name lives on in so many other ways.
September 14th, 2008 at 10:35 pm
Many employees benightedly try to establish a human emotional relationship with their corporate employers, the employees’ ownership (with little or no reservation) of stock in the employer being, in their way of thinking, a sort of comforting affirmation of organizational family - the more stock held the greater the affirmation. Of course employers tend to encourage (subtlely or not so subtlely) this attitude by their employees since, among other things, it tends to buoy the price of the stock.
September 14th, 2008 at 10:40 pm
Thank you, Ronit-
Lovely tribute for a remarkable man & family.
September 14th, 2008 at 11:03 pm
Ronit,
Thank you for a great story on an American institution!
Unbelievable to think of them passing into a history they were so much a part of making.
Dick Swart
September 14th, 2008 at 11:21 pm
My apologies to Ronit.
September 15th, 2008 at 12:41 am
Post removed.
September 15th, 2008 at 12:46 am
An amazing post, Ronit.
Much appreciated.
September 15th, 2008 at 12:49 am
Sure, a vocal critic of McCarthyism, the only voice against communism, liberalism, downright anti-sovereignty, a no good aparatchnick of the FED.
The beginning of the end of these psychopaths that bleed our country.
We need reorganization of our financial predators.
Sic Transit Gloria Mundi, for the country, for country first is what we demand.
September 15th, 2008 at 12:52 am
@ 10 and 12:
As if one Broadband comment isn’t enough.
September 15th, 2008 at 12:53 am
A good article on the man who has been at the center of Lehman Brothers for the last quarter century. It seems like his loyalty to the firm proved to be the firm’s undoing.
September 15th, 2008 at 1:12 am
My thanks as well, Ronit. My prayers are that the Merrill deal holds and the crisis does not spread. Not yet.
September 15th, 2008 at 7:28 am
Thank you for this post, Ronit.
I was thinking of Lehman Hall recently, after seeing it in a photograph taken looking through one of the new buildings — such an appealing, human-scaled structure. I am glad that it was not taken down in the new construction zeal.
And in the midst of all the fiddling while Rome burns that’s going on in some of the other threads, how refreshing to read of admirable Gov. Lehman — an authentic leader and someone ready and able to serve in so many capacities.
Mostly my thoughts are with those who must deal with devastation this morning, on Wall Street, Main Street, and the Gulf. May we be blessed with wise and capable leaders who can help us to get through what lies ahead and regain so much that is lost or lies in peril.
September 15th, 2008 at 11:19 am
How bad do you think this is going to get David?
I would asppreciate a good post from an Eph Economist on the state of our economy, and the reasons we are seeing so many banks go under.
September 15th, 2008 at 12:42 pm
An interesting Lehman Tidbit…
It seems that FDR was somewhat unwilling to run for NY Governor in 1928 largely due to his interests/investment in Warm Springs. It was only after strong appeals from the Dem. Party and Lehman himself agreeing to serve as Lt. Gov. (and shoulder most of the burden of governing) that FDR agreed.
It’s clear that FDR planned to run eventually, but it’s not clear when or how successful he’d have been if he waited. So if you like the New Deal, you can, in a sense, thank an Eph for that too.
Source. See pg. 104/105
September 15th, 2008 at 2:26 pm
1) Great post! Thanks to Ronit. Also, I second the recommendation of The House of Morgan.
2) As to PTC question, we are in a recession. How bad will it be and how long will it last? I don’t know.
September 15th, 2008 at 3:08 pm
Ken Layne answers PTC’s question in typically brilliant fashion.
September 15th, 2008 at 5:05 pm
Fascinating post, but I have a minor quibble: I don’t think everybody at Lehman will lose their jobs, at least right away.
Lehman filed for Chapter 11, which allows it to continue its operations. If Lehman had filed for Chapter 7, then it would shut its doors and cease business operations.
No doubt there will be significant layoffs, but there will be quite a few left behind, at least in the short run.
September 15th, 2008 at 9:17 pm
See David’s response above for an assessment on the economy. As to the second part of your question: long story short, banks depend on borrowed funds to keep things going swimmingly.
In the case of commercial banks, most of these funds come from customer deposits. Commercial banks will also depend on borrowing money through short-term lending, but worst-case, they have customer deposits to fall back on. They simply stop lending money and effect “lend” money to themselves.
In the case of investment banks with no customer deposits (not in the traditional “bank” sense anyway), these parties depend on their creditworthiness and market confidence to continue borrowing short-term funds to fund longer-term investments. Hence the rub.
If customers make a run on a commercial bank, which we’ve certainly seen, then they’re basically SOL. If markets cease buying an investment bank’s debt, it’s basically SOL. That’s what we saw with Bear Stearns, except Uncle Sam stepped in and risked taxpayer dollars to keep it from Chapter 11. Lehman was not quite as lucky, as the government refused to back any deals to buy up Lehman.